Appakutty Movie Review:
Both creators and consumers of the 'Parenting 101' posts by baby-bloggers raising 'a king with chivalry' or a 'queen with standards' fail to understand that these good manners often expire soon in a world that is rarely fair. One wonders how children are expected to reconcile the values they are taught at home with the bitterness, prejudices, and animosities they are made to inherit from the adults around them. The same adults trying to instil values in children through these videos and posts often come across as hypocritical. Mu Maran's Appakutty is an inconsistent exploration of a child caught between the egos of 'informed adults'. This could have been an extraordinary film if it had focused solely on this conflict, instead of trying to squeeze into the familiar hero-villain and hero-heroine templates.
Suriya (Vijay Antony), a single father grieving the loss of his wife, flees a group of goons to save himself and his daughter, Thiya (Lithanya), to live in peace somewhere far from Chennai. In a quaint town nestled amidst Ooty's mist, trouble finds Suriya again. It's a different kind of trouble. Suriya and Thiya are forced to be on the run again; this time it is after Thiya's teacher, Anitha (Preethi Asrani), falls in love with him.
Nothing illustrates how weak the writing of a film is better than a 130-minute film feeling much longer. Mu Maran seems to have thrown a lot of weight behind the twists he introduces in the first half and second half. However, the work in between these twist scenes is basic or, in the worst case, even below that. The enormity you feel in the runtime could be attributed to the lack of discretion in which scenes or sequences needed more time, and which ones less. The first half, for the most part, is a tiring watch as scene after scene is bombarded to convey how much Surya loves his daughter Thiya when it was already communicated effectively very long ago. In films like this where the protagonist remains low-key and under the radar, every new person he meets and every new occurrence he is subjected to should take him closer to jeopardy. However, Appakutty, while maintaining this template, introduces him to a very different problem. And that problem did not require adherence to this template.
Cast: Vijay Antony, Lithanya, Preethi Asrani, Haripriya Isai, Aruvi Madhan, Bagavathi Perumal, Haritha, Haripriya
Director: Mu Maran
The romantic portions featuring Anitha pursuing Suriya simply had no soul in them. As it progresses and gets complex during the second half, the equation between Suriya and Anitha is left dangling, and the latter's presence merely serves as a convenient conduit to help the protagonist accomplish something. It is appreciated that Vijay Antony was willing to relegate himself to the background in the second half. But that choice does not pay off, as the other major characters introduced in the latter half of the film merely end up adding to the number of actors. Instead of endlessly dishing out scene after scene to tell how Surya will do anything for Thiya, work needed to go into the emotional weight of Megala (Haripriya Isai) and Suresh (Aruvi Madhan) too. Their anger, frustration, trauma, and reconciliation remain distant till the very end. The film also fails to exploit the potential to explore a couple of unhappy marriages in it.
Having said that, the biggest factor working in favour of Appakutty is the emotional exchanges between Suriya and Thiya. In fact, this is the only interpersonal relationship the makers have focused on and the audience member really cares about. Suriya and Thiya's bond gets dense towards the end to the point of tearing up the one watching. Lithanya, for her age, has understood the assignment and has delivered a powerful performance that almost magically makes up for the loose ends. Also, considering Vijay Antony's personal loss, he seems to have fully channelled it into this role. What the writing denies to Suriya, Vijay Antony gives. The film gains more cohesion as the proceedings shift to the court. The praise for the court portions does not hinge on the authenticity in depicting the functions of a court. Tamil cinema, since its inception, has been utilising the court of justice to dramatic effect, and Appakutty too excels in doing the same. What makes these scenes welcome is the failed opportunities to create drama elsewhere. Sprinklings of humour are a hit-and-miss. While evoking mild chuckles in some places, in others they are highly unwelcome given the rise in emotional stakes.
Appakutty in a nutshell is a flawed, yet beautiful subversion of fatherhood. There is a sense of warmth beneath the shortcomings, like underdeveloped characterisations, forced humour, and romance. A solid idea, like children unnecessarily being made to trudge along carrying the animosity between their parents, which they don't even fully understand, required a more sincere screenplay to truly do it justice. Vijay Antony's Suriya accepts every humiliation for his daughter's well-being. And the daughter, in return, salvages her Appakutty, both in the film and outside of it.