Sardar 2 first reviews: Is Karthi-PS Mithran's sequel only average?

While Karthi's performance has been receiving praise, the screenplay and background score of Sardar 2 are being criticised
Sardar 2 first reviews: Is Karthi-PS Mithran's sequel only average?
Karthi (L) and SJ Suryah (R) in posters for Sardar 2
Updated on

The much-awaited sequel to Karthi's Sardar finally hit theatres on Thursday. With SJ Suryah, Malavika Mohanan and Ashika Ranganath joining the cast this time, Sardar 2 sees PS Mithran return to the director's chair.

The film brings back Karthi in his dual roles as Indian spy Chandra Bose, aka Sardar, and his son, police officer Vijay Prakash, while expanding the franchise with S J Suryah as the antagonist Black Dagger. Rajisha Vijayan also returns from the first film.

Sardar 2 first reviews: Is Karthi-PS Mithran's sequel only average?
Sardar 2 editor Vijay Velukutty: My association with Ajith Kumar sir made me who I am

While the film's first show in Chennai is coming to an end, audiences have already started sharing their opinion about the sequel. With the international premiere set a little in advance compared to the Indian premiere, some reviews have already been published on X by overseas movie buffs.

So far, Sardar 2 has been receiving mixed reviews, with appreciation for Karthi's performance and PS Mithran's writing. However, there are also criticisms against the screenplay, with some saying the film's messaging overpowers entertainment. Many have also criticised the background score for the film.

Disclaimer: The reviews and opinions featured in this article are sourced from posts on X (formerly Twitter) and reflect the individual opinions of the respective users. They do not represent the views or opinions of Cinema Express.

Sardar 2 first reviews: Is Karthi-PS Mithran's sequel only average?
Karthi's Sardar 2 gets U/A certification from CBFC

One user wrote, "Decent movie, definitely not that bad as manipulated online reviews. Good message too. Bad climax and worst worst BGM which is a big letdown for this genre. Watchable movie."

One user praised the film, suggesting that the story commences from the very first fram and that it features a "banger interval block." However, the netizen also opined that the second half is average.

One user praised Karthi's performance but disliked the writing for SJ Suryah's character. Their opinion read, "Karthi justifies the dual roles, but the rest is a letdown! SJ Suryah’s characterisation feels weak. Poor BGM & CGI, convenient writing, zero logic, no real twists, lengthy runtime and pointless action blocks. The only positives: stays true to the core spy plot without unnecessary love tracks/songs, and the antibiotic-resistance message is good. Overall, a DISAPPOINTMENT!"

Another user said the film is a must-watch. "This second chapter is really worth watching. Karthi did outperform is own self from the first part. Yogi babu - Nizhalgal ravi combo stands out. Malavika mohanan was great. P.S Mithran delivered a solid harsh reality without even trying hard. Must watch," the review read.

Detailing why the film is run of the mill, one user penned, "Again message stands over movie! Has a neat emotional hook btw hero & villain but apart writing is very routine/convinently done missing on the intended race against time conflict feeling stretched & loud."

One review compared the sequel to Sardar. "It went on the same tempo as the first part. Dove deeper into what it means to be once a spy—always a spy with its conclusion; really liked it. Though in the second half the actually message is expressed multiple times with multiple characters that it got preachy," it read.

X
-->
Cinema Express
www.cinemaexpress.com