Enable Javscript for better performance
Rose Island Movie Review: An interesting story that disappoints at the end- Cinema express

Rose Island Movie Review: An interesting story that ends in disappointment

This Netflix drama about a micro-nation has a lot going for it but ruins it all with a poor third act

Published: 16th December 2020

In 1968, an engineer named Giorgio Rosa built an island off the coast of Rimini, Italy and declared it as an independent state. Rose Island was a symbol of freedom that Giorgio felt wasn’t possible in the modern world. The island began attracting huge crowds, and people from across the world revoked their original citizenship to become a Rose Islander. The buzz that the man-made island created did not agree with the State and the Church. What followed led to some of the most crucial moments in the history of Italy and the world.

Director: Sydney Sibilia

Cast: Elio Germano, Matilda De Angelis, Luca Zingaretti, Tom Wlaschiha

Streaming on: Netflix​

Rose Island begins as a comical retelling of this story, which centers on the rising conflict between the Italian government and the self-proclaimed heads of the Rose Island. Various subplots like Giorgio’s quest for freedom, his conflicted relationships with his home, love interest Gabriella (Matilda De Angelis), and the society, do aid in driving the story forward. However, the film loses steam around the halfway mark.

The way Giorgio (Elio Germano) blooms as a character keeps the proceedings interesting. Also, the David–Goliath scenario between Rose Island and Italy makes it easy for us to root for Giorgio. Elio's impressive performance almost makes us wish we were citizens of Rose Island too. Apart from his charming and relentless attempts to realise his dream, it is the eccentricity of his character that stands out. Take, for instance, Giorgio’s self-made car and the events that follow. Such details are so brilliantly weaved into the story that it helps us wrap our mind around the freedom he aspires for.

Special mention to actors Leonardo Lidi, Tom Wlaschiha, Violetta Zironi, and Alberto Astorri, who play regular inhabitants of the island (and also the heads of the state). Their introduction scenes garner a few chuckles and their performances pique our interest.

What pulls down these positives is the aimless writing that makes us lose interest in most of the characters. In a film that is based on a true story, it hurts that a few characters, in retrospect, only end up as dead weights. Even the comedy tapers down as the film progresses without any 'wow' factor.

Rose Island is a film that loses it all with a poor third act. When the conflict between the nations reaches a boiling point, it gives you hope at leaving an everlasting footprint, only to take it away instantly with the way it all ends.

In a film like this, one big moment towards the end is what you subconsciously look for. When that eventually happens, even though this is a real-life story, there’s a feeling of something amiss with the screenwriting. Suddenly, the makers want you to feel that Gabriella is as important as the island to Giorgio. Though the film, in retrospect, has justified the final sequence between Gabriella and Giorgio, it feels boring. When the closing shot moves away from the setting, we wish we too had absolute freedom, like Giorgio, but in choosing how such movie experiences end.

Related Articles


Disclaimer : We respect your thoughts and views! But we need to be judicious while moderating your comments. All the comments will be moderated by the newindianexpress.com editorial. Abstain from posting comments that are obscene, defamatory or inflammatory, and do not indulge in personal attacks. Try to avoid outside hyperlinks inside the comment. Help us delete comments that do not follow these guidelines.

The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.


Which is your favourite time travel film in Tamil?

Indru Netru Naalai